Effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines will rely on public trust

By Samantha Black, PhD, ScienceBoard editor in chief

No matter how effective upcoming COVID-19 vaccines are, their ultimate success in combating the pandemic will depend on how much the public trusts the safety and efficacy of the products. That's according to a panel of physicians and scientists who discussed COVID-19 vaccine trials in a briefing on October 29.

Studies of SARS-CoV-2 infection have shown that patients with more severe cases of COVID-19 have a greater antibody response than those with mild cases of the disease. This is "reflective of an arms race between the virus and the immune system," said Sean Diehl, PhD, an associate professor at the University of Vermont Larner College of Medicine, in the briefing organized by Newswise.

The immune system has mechanisms in place to detect replicating viruses in the early stages of infection, with more viral material being made as the virus spreads. As the system gets the virus under control, the neutralizing antibodies remain in the body, which explains why patients with more severe cases of infection have more antibodies.

As an example of the durability of antibodies, Diehl explained that individuals who had the original SARS-CoV virus from 2003 were recently rebled, 17 years after exposure, and they still retained strong neutralizing antibody responses and antigen-specific memory T-cell responses. As the viral characteristics of SARS-CoV are in the same antigenic family as SARS-CoV-2, this bodes well for long-term protection from antibodies against COVID-19, Diehl said.

Although these antibody responses are from natural infection and not vaccination, many vaccine manufacturers plan to follow vaccine trial volunteers for up to 26 months to examine the durability of the vaccine antibody response.

Many scientists believe that a rise in antibodies may confer some level of protection if an individual is reinfected with SARS-CoV-2. However, Dr. Robert Salata, a professor of medicine, epidemiology, and international health at University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, said that "given that 47 million people around the world have been infected, and there are only a handful of scientifically documented reinfection cases, that [reinfection is] still few and far between at this point in time."

Many of the COVID-19 vaccines being developed are aiming for a minimum efficacy rate of 50% to 60%, meaning that a vaccine would protect against infection in 50 to 60 out of 100 recipients who are exposed to the virus. To achieve herd immunity, an efficacy rate of at least 70% must be achieved, if all individuals receive a vaccine.

Vaccine trials in younger populations

According to Salata, Pfizer's phase II/III clinical trial of its vaccine in development will continue to vaccinate children between the ages of 12 and 17 into November. He explained that as we "get to the point of general distribution of vaccines in the U.S. and other countries, we want to know that it's also safe and effective in children."

There are 74 million children in the U.S. who have not been studied, except to date in the Pfizer trial, despite the fact that children seem to be less likely to get COVID-19 and that they can be excellent carriers of viruses. As some of the most important carriers of infection to the home, it is critical that vaccines be studied in children, according to speaker Dr. Stephen Spector, a professor of pediatrics at the University of California, San Diego.

One vaccine will not be enough

Vaccines alone will not end the COVID-19 pandemic, but they will be one tool that decreases the circulation of SARS-CoV-2 in the population, and vaccination efforts should be combined with all other public health measures, Spector said.

"[A single vaccine] will add to the amount of antibody responses and T-cell responses in the general population," Salata said. "And hopefully we'll get to that level of herd immunity that was already mentioned, but it will take a while, and we will not be able to move away from these strict public health measures in the interim."

For instance, Pfizer has committed to providing the U.S. with 100 million doses of its vaccine, but given that the vaccine requires two separate injections, this will only cover 50 million people. With 325 million to 330 million individuals, Salata said it will take multiple vaccine platforms due to "sheer numbers and distribution issues."

"We are going to need multiple options -- bottom line," Salata advised.

As a silver lining, all the public health measures currently in place to reduce COVID-19 transmission -- such as social distancing and mask wearing -- are probably also very effective against other respiratory viruses, including influenza and respiratory syncytial virus.

Public trust in vaccines

The behavioral aspects of human nature play as much a role in the efficacy of vaccines as the biological aspects, according to Perry Halkitis, PhD, MPH, dean of the Rutgers School of Public Health. He explained that people have a difficult time maintaining behaviors, and a lack of personal responsibility and altruism makes it easy for individuals to think that they are immune without considering that other people may be more susceptible to the disease.

If this is true and these individuals don't buy into the idea of getting the vaccine, then they may continue to spread the disease and prevent vaccine and public health efforts from being effective.

"Once these vaccines are approved, we want to make sure that there is public trust in these vaccines, because nothing will be effective if the people don't take it," said speaker Dr. Shobha Swaminathan, an associate professor at the Rutgers New Jersey Medical School.

Regarding the recent pauses in the AstraZeneca and Johnson & Johnson vaccine trials, these companies have moved ahead after resolving concerns about the safety and potential side effects of their vaccine candidates, according to Dr. Edward Jones-Lopez, an assistant professor at Keck Medicine of the University of Southern California.

"This is really about sending a very important message to the public" that the system is functioning as intended and safety standards are being meticulously maintained, he said.

The future of COVID-19 vaccines

As time goes on, "we will learn more about how the virus behaves and be able to design better and better vaccines," Diehl noted. Many of the vaccines currently being developed only use one part of the virus; they are, therefore, an important stopgap measure, but they will not provide full protection as with live-attenuated vaccines.

Previous outbreaks have provided proof of concept for being able to respond better to future outbreaks and an understanding of how to move new technologies through regulatory pipelines, according to Diehl.

Do you have a unique perspective on your research related to vaccines or clinical development? Contact the editor today to learn more.


Most antibody responses to SARS-CoV-2 are strong and long-lasting
How long does the immune response last in patients with the SARS-CoV-2 virus? This has been a key question in shaping the public health response to the...
New model could improve vaccine, immunotherapy design
A new model used to predict the outcomes of pathogen detection systems as a function of innate immunity may lead to more effective cancer immunotherapies...
Who should get the 1st COVID-19 vaccines?
Once a vaccine for SARS-CoV-2 is approved by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to be administered to the public, who should receive it first, given...
Will mutation of the SARS-CoV-2 virus affect vaccine effectiveness?
What impact will mutation of the SARS-CoV-2 virus have on the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines that are in development? In a new study published in...
FDA issues guidance on submitting EUA requests for COVID-19 vaccines
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) on October 6 issued a new guidance with recommendations for developers of COVID-19 vaccines regarding the...

Copyright © 2020 scienceboard.net

Science Advisory Board on LinkedIn
Science Advisory Board on Facebook
Science Advisory Board on Twitter